Does Poland Want to Chemically Castrate Roman Polanski?
Rohin Guha
September 28, 2009
A few dots for you: Acclaimed auteur Roman Polanski is arrested; Poland legally mandates chemical castration for proven pedophiles; Poland is also among those who want Polanski freed on bail. So, when connected, the dots form kind of a damning line that puts Polanski first in line to forcibly rendered impotent by the Polish government. And yes, Twitter's already buzzing about the way-too-coincidental timing of both gear-shifts in our international legal system. Although the larger question remains that if he committed this horrible offense on American soil, should Poland (or even France), clearly a little too trigger-happy, have any say about when or to whom he's released? Also, if Polanski's wife is poised to forgive him, should we?
These are matters heavier than what some of you make of Jessica Simpson, but the facts are pretty clear-cut. With Polanski, the Polish government stands to make an example for less highly-profiled sex offenders. Probably more offensive than the evident human rights issue is how glaringly sheep-in-wolf’s clothing and the Franco-Polish liberation effort is. Foreign Ministers from both countries have gone as far as to appeal to Hillary Clinton on Polanski’s behalf. Almost as if reps from both governments entered into a shady back-alley pact to put this business to bed. And then we have to wonder: Is this case even worth trying if the victim is decidedly over it and no longer cares to call for Polanski’s head on a platter?
Comments (2)
Posted by Pambigua on Tue Oct 6, 2009 at 09.39 am
I’d agree with Todd. Yes, it was decades ago, and yes, U.S. law is often hypocritically puritanical about sex, but we’re talking about the rape of someone who was drugged. I love his work but have to say I’m appalled at how quickly his filmmaker friends stampeded to his defense, and how their indignance dripped with a those-quaint-Americans indignance. I think of myself as a sexual libertarian but I’ll welcome the “quaint” label when it comes to the drug-induced rape of a 13-year old.
Post a Comment
Anonymous comments are moderated. To comment instantly, register with BlackBook. Click here to login.


Posted by Todd on Tue Sep 29, 2009 at 12.06 pm
The purpose of the criminal punishment isn’t to get revenge for the victims, it is deter criminal activity and protect people from future harm. Letting Polanski go, sends out the message that the wealthy and famous can do whatever they want, which just encourages the elite to committ crimes.