New York: Top 10 Brooklyn Restaurants Worth the Wait
October 07, 2009
● Flatbush Farm (Prospect Heights) - Everything you'd expect from a restaurant with "Farm" in the name: local, organic, sustainable. Decor is more modern than country, save for the bangin' backyard overflowing with green.
● Vinegar Hill House (Dumbo) - Cast iron dishes, straight from the wood fire oven, are killer tasty and surprisingly affordable. Mismatched knickknacks and vintage furniture make the space a real charmer.
● Rose Water (Park Slope) - It's not surprising that a seasonal menu helps the coop crowd get off. Park Slope's favorite date spot comes with flickering candles and chocolate pot de crème.
● Buttermilk Channel (Carroll Gardens) - Brooklyn’s M.V.P. in the fancy-fried-chicken craze serves their birds with cheddar waffles. A clean interior—large windows, industrial lighting, dark wood floors—is the epitome of Brooklyn chic.
● James (Prospect Heights) - Hidden in the first floor of a brownstone, the restaurant draws a neighborhood crowd, but the food—New American with local ingredients—is worth a commute.
● Al di Là (Park Slope) - Park Slope’s favorite Italian job comes with the longest wait. Rustic fare (pork loin scallopine, tagliatelle al ragu, roasted duck) is served in a purposefully deteriorating dining room.
● Franny’s (Prospect Heights) - Ultra-thin pizza fancied up with super fresh—and yes, you guessed it, sustainable—toppings like clams and mussels. Husband and wife owners don’t skimp on the salads or apps, either.
● Acqua Santa (Williamsburg)- The romantic, go-to spot for the more committed hipster types. Italian favorites, like spaghetti puttanesca and fettucine amatriciana, are easily paired with a bottle of vino.
● Applewood (Park Slope)- Mom and pop joint serves up responsible food in a cozy, ski-lodge setting; think fireplace, wooden tables, and flowers. The meal won’t weigh as heavily on your conscience as it will your wallet.
● The Good Fork (Red Hook)- A reason to go to Red Hook other than IKEA. This eclectic restaurant serves global bites like Korean style steak and eggs, as well as neighborhood favorites like Steve’s Key lime pie.
Comments (14)
Posted by Poppy on Thu Oct 8, 2009 at 09.30 am
Franny’s is an excellent restaurant, which people love to hate. The pizza’s are fine, but the highlights are their pastas and appetizers, all beautifully prepared and guaranteed to be made up of the best possible ingredients. If you are in the neighborhood it is a solid choice.
Posted by Bubba on Thu Oct 8, 2009 at 12.23 pm
Wow, 10 restaurants within 1.3 miles of each other, really?
Posted by Rachael on Thu Oct 8, 2009 at 01.58 pm
great list! i love vinegar hill house, definitely one of my favorites. thanks for the suggestions!
Posted by Daniel Johnston on Thu Oct 8, 2009 at 01.58 pm
I think this list is just great.
Posted by Jesse on Thu Oct 8, 2009 at 01.59 pm
Personally, I’m not a huge fan of ALL of these places, but Vinegar Hill House… Al Di La… Applewood… those places are total gems.
Also… The Good Fork and Aqua Santa are about 6 miles from eachother. ;)
Posted by Meredith on Thu Oct 8, 2009 at 02.04 pm
Agreed, Franny’s appetizers are fantastic. Glad to see Applewood on this list (best drinks in brooklyn!), and look forward to checking out some of these other recommendations.
Posted by aa on Thu Oct 8, 2009 at 03.16 pm
Does the wait at Fat Sal’s count? That place always takes forever. But its worth it.
Buttermilk Channel = Overrated
Rose Water = SO GOOD
Vinegar Hill House = Unreal
Posted by tom murphy on Thu Oct 8, 2009 at 04.42 pm
Where’s Nathan’s?
Posted by po from brooklyn on Thu Oct 8, 2009 at 06.36 pm
wow, A Bistro wasn’t even mentioned.
Post a Comment
Anonymous comments are moderated. To comment instantly, register with BlackBook. Click here to login.


Posted by Mona on Thu Oct 8, 2009 at 08.40 am
Really, Franny’s?? So overrated. I dont think any reviewer ever actually eats there. I think they just read other reviews and base their review on that. It’s fine food but definitely does not deserve to be listed in top 10, not even close. Rose Water is eh. I think Jena and whoever helped you out on this needs to expand their Brooklyn scope. Sadly, most of my top 10 have closed in this crippling economy :(