Captain Jim's Seafood

If it looks like a fish market from the outside, that's because it is (with fresh catches directly provided by Jim Hanson's fleet in Key Largo), but don't let that stop you from going inside if you're hungry. Almost any of the fish you see on ice are served in the adjoining restaurant, and these folks know how to prepare them better than just about anyone else in town. No need to get all fancy; a mahi-mahi sandwich with the special sauce will have you seeing stars.