The Hamptons » Restaurant » Sag Harbor » American (New)
New Paradise Cafe
Editorial Review
With a Moby-Dick logo and creaky wood floors, the Paradise maintains some of the literary cache it had when it shared the space with a bookshop. Twists on standards like house favorite spice-rubbed rack of lamb keep the dining room packed at all times. Locals still haven't forgotten the doner the previously called the space home, but fixture Howie (“from O’Mally’s”), nearly an institution himself, at the bar and owner Robert Durkin give the place, converted from a local diner, a deeper sense of local heritage than it might deserve.
Features
- Outdoor Area
- Bar Food
- Bar Scene
- Brunch Standout
Attributes
-
Price:
$$$ -
Reservations:
Recommended -
Vibe:
Bustling/Boisterous - Restaurant Type:
American (New)
Similar Listings Nearby
- 8 W. Water St., The Hamptons 11963
- 631-725-7088
- Visit the site
The Beacon
Boats bobbing, buoys dinging, and, yes, the bartender’s barking all roll into one idyllic din and set the stage for some excellent French-inflected fare, such as halibut baked in parchment. The sce... read more
Search guide
Featured Listings
-
Agave
There is more to life than Patron Silver, is there not? Agave promi...
-
Banzai Burger
The scene is always chilly-chill at this beachy spot in Amagansett,...
-
18 Bay
Long a Bayville favorite known for making the most of local ingredi...
-
Haute Hippie
The Boho-chic line Haute Hippie gets its own shop in Southampton, i...
-
La Maison Blanche
Sometimes a brand new hotel can feel like an old one in all the rig...
