New York » Restaurant » Downtown Manhattan » American (New)

One If By Land Two If By Sea

Editorial Review

Listen my children, and you shall hear...Aaron Burr's sumptuous carriage house is true romance: flowers, firelight, and a piano that plays the lilting soundtrack to your dream date. New chef brings a lighter, modern touch, although succulent roasted lamb remains. Maine scallop sashimi app is lemony pureness. Follow duck breast with creamy peanut butter fondant. Dedicated romancers can throw down $125 for a full chef's tasting menu—the only thing hotter is the fire in your new fiancée's eyes, you charming bastard. This gateway-into-lifetime-love-cum-night-of-sophistication is worth the splurge.

Features

  • Classic
  • Desserts Exceptional
  • Private Parties
  • Prix-Fixe
  • Wine List Extensive
  • Brunch Standout
  • Celeb Sightings
  • Fine Dining
  • Historic Setting
  • Live Music
  • Notable Chef
  • Romantic Dining

Attributes

  • Price:
    $$$$
  • Reservations:
    Recommended
  • Alcohol:
    Full Bar
  • Vibe:
    Romantic/Date Spot, Locals
  • Restaurant Type:
    American (New)

Similar Listings Nearby

business thumbnail

Perilla

West Babylon’s own Harold Dieterle takes down Top Chef, turns his attention to the WVill. Lots of potential in this spin-off. Name reflects Chinese basil, available in coconut cake fro-yo dessert. ... read more

business thumbnail

Cornelia Street Cafe

Historic downstairs spot hosts histrionic poetry readings and a science series that draws more Nobel laureates than you can shake a particle accelerator at—if you're smart, you'll reserve tickets f... read more

Search guide

Featured Listings

  • business thumbnail

    Melissa

    If Willy Wonka had gone into shoes instead of candy, Melissa's plas...

  • business thumbnail

    Empellon Cocina

    Iron Chef Alex Stupak, late of pastry duties at Alinea and wd~50, c...

  • business thumbnail

    Don Antonio

    Neapolitan pie dream team. Kesté's Roberto Caporuscio joins ...

  • business thumbnail

    Super Linda

    Not inspired by an action hero accountant, more like "super pretty,...

  • business thumbnail

    Buddha Beer Bar

    Craft beer meets Korean-American fusion at Washington Heights gastr...