The Hamptons » Restaurant » LIE » American

Peter Luger

Editorial Review

Aficionados claim that this second location of the Brooklyn institution is missing something: the old ovens that give the steak a little something extra (years of grime?). But this claim may be a bit like those who say the Rolling Stones sound better on vinyl—surely true, but when the meat's this good is it worth arguing about? It might also lack the old-world charm and gruff staff of the original, but it is easier to get a table here and you're closer to the beach.

Features

  • Cash Only
  • Classic
  • Bar/Lounge on Premises

Attributes

  • Price:
    $$$$
  • Reservations:
    Recommended
  • Vibe:
    Locals
  • Restaurant Type:
    American, German, Steak

Search guide

Featured Listings

  • business thumbnail

    C.Wonder

    Preview: J. Christopher Burch's C. Wonder will be--literally--poppi...

  • business thumbnail

    Nammos Estiatorio

    What about the former Nello’s Summertime spot appeals so much...

  • business thumbnail

    Beaumarchais East Hampton

    Screw the sliced cantaloupe and single complimentary mimosa, brunch...

  • business thumbnail

    Smokin' Wolf

    Turtle Crossing might be gone this year, but fans of the longtime P...

  • business thumbnail

    Zum Schneider MTK

    With 12 beers on tap (4 of which are served here exclusively) and t...