The American Hotel

Vintage rules at this century-old Sag Harbor landmark. Victorian fireplaces, mounted moose heads and enough antiques to make your grandmother swoon. Book far in advance, as there are only eight elegantly-styled rooms—each with private sitting area and Jacuzzi bathtub—and scores of three-named patrons eager to snag them. a The privileged patio offers prime Sag Harbor people-watching, French-American fare, and one of the country’s most famous wine lists (1,700 selections!)