The Hamptons » Restaurant » Amagansett » Seafood

The Lobster Roll

business thumbnail

Editorial Review

Don’t be discouraged by the wooden shack-like exterior, or the fenced-in picnic table seating or the lack of designer sunglasses. There’s a reason why this seasonal seafood joint in Napeague (nicknamed LUNCH due to the prominent sign on its roof) has developed a loyal 40-year following, and it ain’t the ambiance. Stick with the seafood, specifically the famous lobster salad served on a hot dog bun. Scarf it down on a bench with paper placemats and plastic cups—the way it was intended.

Features

  • Outdoor Area

Attributes

  • Price:
    $
  • Reservations:
    Not Necessary
  • Alcohol:
    Beer & Wine
  • Vibe:
    Locals
  • Restaurant Type:
    Seafood

Similar Listings Nearby

business thumbnail
  • 2095 Montauk Hwy., The Hamptons 11930
  • 631-604-5102

Mahon's Seafood Shack

Mahons' on the the sand swept Napeague Stretch brings fresh seafood right at the shore. Contemporary American roadside seafood with a touch of classy French influence makes casual dining scrumptiou... read more

business thumbnail
  • 2167 Montauk Hwy., The Hamptons 11954
  • 631-267-7993

Cyril's Fish House

Arrive early to find a seat and you just might find a companion. Cyril’s serves up satisfying seafood like Cajun calamari and reggae beats to put you in the mood. Depending on the luck of you... read more

Search guide

Featured Listings

  • business thumbnail

    Agave

    There is more to life than Patron Silver, is there not? Agave promi...

  • business thumbnail

    Banzai Burger

    The scene is always chilly-chill at this beachy spot in Amagansett,...

  • business thumbnail

    18 Bay

    Long a Bayville favorite known for making the most of local ingredi...

  • business thumbnail

    Haute Hippie

    The Boho-chic line Haute Hippie gets its own shop in Southampton, i...

  • business thumbnail

    La Maison Blanche

    Sometimes a brand new hotel can feel like an old one in all the rig...