The Hamptons - Montauk - Hotels

161 Second House Rd., The Hamptons 11954
631-668-2877

Ruschmeyer's

Another dive-y family motel has been reborn into a hipster haven in Montauk: This time it's the Second House Tavern, with Ben Pundole and Rob McKinley (part owners of the Surf Lodge) teaming up wit... read more

183 Edgemere St., The Hamptons 11954
631-668-2632

Surf Lodge

The first in what the hoteliers plan as a brand, the Lodge steals some of Balazs' Sunset Beach thunder with this hip and off-the-high-heel-beaten track in Montauk. Each of the well-apponted bungalo... read more

90 Second House Rd., The Hamptons 11954
631-668-2105

Solé East

This boutiquey 60-roomer just off Fort Pond benefits from a recent refresh of an old'20s-era inn. Pretty posh by Montauk standards. Prices remain a little lofty, but amazing what a fresh paint job,... read more

4 Old West Lake Dr., The Hamptons 11954
631-668-2077

The Crow's Nest Inn & Restaurant

Beloved Montauk classic born again following a major upgrade in service and amenities, as NYC hotelier Sean MacPherson is now running the show at the 18-unit (including two-bedroom cottage) hotel a... read more

32 Star Island , The Hamptons 11954
631-668-3100

Montauk Yacht Club

After a multi-million-dollar reno in 2009, the MYC, which has sat on 35 acres of water-front property on Montauk's Star Island since 1929, emerged radically changed, yet still maintains a certain b... read more

272 Old Montauk Highway, The Hamptons 11954
631-668-3000

Panoramic View

There isn't a single room in this joint that doesn't have an oceanfront view. Oh, and that ocean? It's all yours. The beach is for guests only. Lawn chairs and towel service provided. With no bar o... read more

40 Deforest Rd., The Hamptons 11954
631-668-2334

The East Deck Motel

Sure, all the kids whose idea of catching waves consists nearly entirely of Johnny Utah in "Point Break" and one Kelly Slater video are flocking to the Surf Lodge, but this is the real deal. The lo... read more

290 Old Montauk Highway, The Hamptons 11954
631-668-2345

Gurney's Inn Resort, Spa & Conference Center

Pricey inn set atop a hill is one of the most scenic outposts in Montauk. Diners enjoy clear views of crashing waves below, and walk off their meals on the private beach designated for paying custo... read more