While it may be trying a little too hard for a classic old-time-y vibe, the steaks are nonetheless quite good.
Al fresco in front or back and a Euro-mod flair keep things light
A marina setting with strong drink, salty sailors, and saltier food.
Fresh seafood and produce speak loudest at unassuming roadside spot known for breakfast (but full of surprises).
- Fellingham's
- Southampton
-
American, American (New), Burgers
-
$
An sudsy spot where old salts congregate at dawn, but you can stop for a burger at a more reasonable hour.
- Fresno
- East Hampton
-
American (New)
-
$$$
New American at a cozy spot filled with a less agro crowd than some of its Newtown Lane counterparts
Seaside Montauk staple serves up fresh seafood and local flavor
Basic dependable tavern that gets easily overrun sometimes.
Top Pick!
The ridiculously popular Meeting House lives up to its name.
The Paradise feels so at home in Sag that it might soon lose its "new."
The insouciant staff is nearly as authentic as the food.
- Sunset Beach
- Shelter Island
-
American (New), Bistro, French
-
$$$
Top Pick!
If the Meatpacking District could go on vacay, it would choose Sunset Beach.
- The Backyard
- Montauk
-
American (New), Eclectic & Global, Seafood
-
$$$
Top Pick!
Some tempting dishes and a sultry vibe seduce loungers in Solé East's backyard.
Beloved local joint makes it trumphant return.
- The Corner Bar
- Sag Harbor
-
American, Burgers, Hot Dogs, Soups/Sandwiches
-
$
Not Manhattan's Corner Bistro, but yeah, the burgers are good.
Casual, healthy grill is fun for all ages and shares million dollar view/location with the American Legion Post.
Those clever locals want this spot all to themselves come sunset.
White table cloth steakhouse standby is the new kid on the block as far as the olde time East Hampton locale is concerned.
1 - 18 of 18 |
