Search guide
Refine by Restaurant Type:
American American (New) Asian Austrian BBQ Burgers German Health Food International Irish More »
- 4 S. Elmwood Ave., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-283-5963
Zum Schneider MTK
With 12 beers on tap (4 of which are served here exclusively) and three sizes for each one ranging from large to ridiculously large, means this place has more steins than lower Manhattan, because p... read more
- 41 S. Euclid Ave., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-3212
The Coast
Two local couples are the force behind the new-this-season restaurant. The dark blue walls and antique oak bar add a cooling influence on the space, which can fill quickly with folk all trying to s... read more
- 148 South Emerson Ave., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-647-8000
The Sloppy Tuna
What to say when new owners clean up a neighborhood dive, and the cleaner nicer place goes by the potentially offiensive moniker The Sloppy Tuna? Not much, really. It's a faux-dive beach bar, but t... read more
- 161 Second House Rd., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-2877
Ruschmeyer's
Another dive-y family motel has been reborn into a hipster haven in Montauk: This time it's the Second House Tavern, with Ben Pundole and Rob McKinley (part owners of the Surf Lodge) teaming up wit... read more
- 17 South Edison St., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-4200
South Edison
It's not your average Montauk restaurant that offers cherry cola braised Berkshire pork belly and mixes fermented black garlic mayonnaise into its lobster roll, but this newcomer situated right bet... read more
- 364 West Lake Dr., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-6592
The Hideaway
The name is no joke. The Hideaway is hidden in the back of Diamond Cove Marina with little more than a red chili pepper hanging from the marina's roadside sign to announce its presence. The open ai... read more
- 32 Star Island Rd., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-3100
The Gulf Coast Kitchen at The Montauk Yacht Club
Don't let the name fool you. Local Montauk fishermen and farmers are the inspiration here, says chef Robbin Haas, who landed at Gulf Coast in 2010 after opening a string of restaurants in South Flo... read more
- 16 Navy Rd., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-6868
Navy Beach
Way out in Montauk on a ramshackle stretch between Hither Hills and Fort Pond, Navy Beach has the view of the sandy bay beachfront, which it is mere yards from, all to itself. Roadhouse primitive o... read more
- 183 Edgemere St., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-238-5216
The Restaurant at the Surf Lodge
There was a lot of buzz around the Surf Lodge when it first opened in 2008. Back then the chef was former Top Cheffer Sam Talbot and paddleboarding was kinda new. Now neither is true. Instead, the ... read more
- 467 East Lake Dr., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-6600
Fishbar
Both rustic and refined, seasonal seafooder splits the difference between a waterfront shack and white-tableclother. Dining on the deck over looking the marina might offer the more rustic experienc... read more
- 90 Second House Rd, The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-9739
The Backyard
Out of the way and away from the scene, The Backyard has created one of its own. Restaurant and lounge behind Solé East offers some sort of alternate-reality boho-chic Montauk: A roadside in... read more
- 541 E. Lake Dr., The Hamptons 11968
- 631-668-4272
Inlet Seafood
Place is owned by a cooperative of six commercial fisherman (they even list their boat names on the menu) who get downright Marxist in their rhetoric. Their "Respect the Ocean, harvest the bounty, ... read more
- 51 Edgemere St., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-2870
East By Northeast
When the most salient feature of your restaurant is the water view, it makes sense to make the building nearly translucent. And ENE's just about achieved that with wraparound floor-to-ceiling windo... read more
- 9 Edison Dr., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-3663
Joni's
Healthy and fresh sandwiches and bites by the seashore -- what more could you ask for? Friendly service and air kisses, you say? Done. If you're stuck for non-dairy and vegetarian options in Mounta... read more
- 382 West Lake Dr., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-6252
West Lake Clam and Chowder House
Waterside hut, doesn't get as packed as it should because of the no-frills ambience (or: intentional lack thereof). Small wooden tables and dark knotted wood walls inside (and the marina out back) ... read more
- 468 W. Lake Dr., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-9190
Dave's Grill
Seafood so fresh, the trawlers that bring it dot the horizon and come in to dock at next door Montauk Harbor—though the dining room is a bit more refined than that might suggest. Reservation ... read more
- 99 Edgemere Rd., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-5005
O'Murphy's Pub
If Montauk had a Cheers it would be O'Murphy's (except Cliff would be a charter boat captain). Everybody knows owners Chet and Jan, who know everybody. Checked tablecloth (green, of course) tables ... read more
- 4 Old West Lake Dr., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-2077
The Crow's Nest Inn & Restaurant
Beloved Montauk classic born again following a major upgrade in service and amenities, as NYC hotelier Sean MacPherson is now running the show at the 18-unit (including two-bedroom cottage) hotel a... read more
- 2167 Montauk Hwy., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-267-7993
Cyril's Fish House
Arrive early to find a seat and you just might find a companion. Cyril’s serves up satisfying seafood like Cajun calamari and reggae beats to put you in the mood. Depending on the luck of you... read more
- 500 West Lake Dr., The Hamptons 11954
- 631-668-2549
Gosman's Topside
Watch fishing boats return home to dock as Hamptons weekenders return to this Montauk classic. Perched atop Gosman's cafe, this staple lunch spot has been serving up local catches and lobster rolls... read more
Featured Listings
-
C.Wonder
Preview: J. Christopher Burch's C. Wonder will be--literally--poppi...
-
Nammos Estiatorio
What about the former Nello’s Summertime spot appeals so much...
-
Beaumarchais East Hampton
Screw the sliced cantaloupe and single complimentary mimosa, brunch...
-
Smokin' Wolf
Turtle Crossing might be gone this year, but fans of the longtime P...
-
Zum Schneider MTK
With 12 beers on tap (4 of which are served here exclusively) and t...
