Family-run joint embodies everything we love about Montauk--casual, fresh, fun.
Don’t let the word “organic” turn you off .
- Dish
- Watermill
-
American (New)
-
$$$
A little restaurant with big surprises.
- Fellingham's
- Southampton
-
American, American (New), Burgers
-
$
An sudsy spot where old salts congregate at dawn, but you can stop for a burger at a more reasonable hour.
- Fresno
- East Hampton
-
American (New)
-
$$$
New American at a cozy spot filled with a less agro crowd than some of its Newtown Lane counterparts
Top Pick!
The ridiculously popular Meeting House lives up to its name.
- Mirko's
- Watermill
-
American (New), Eastern European
-
$$$$
Lily white tablecloths and lilies keep things pretty fancy, but the eclectic menu is a cut above.
In the beachiest part of town, they've upped the anty on beachy.
The Paradise feels so at home in Sag that it might soon lose its "new."
- Sunset Beach
- Shelter Island
-
American (New), Bistro, French
-
$$$
Top Pick!
If the Meatpacking District could go on vacay, it would choose Sunset Beach.
Top Pick!
A little bit of glitz comes to the Montauk with Top Chef hunk Sam Talbot in the kitchen at this big-budget makeover of the Lakeside Inn.
- The Backyard
- Montauk
-
American (New), Eclectic & Global, Seafood
-
$$$
Top Pick!
Some tempting dishes and a sultry vibe seduce loungers in Solé East's backyard.
An open-air spot overlooking the bay
The latest guest at the Maidstone slows things down a little.
- World Pie
- Bridgehampton
-
American (New), Italian, Pizza
-
$$
Top Pick!
The titular pies carry the day, but this is no pizza joint.
- Wyldthyme
- Southampton
-
American, American (New)
-
$$
Thyme and Again branches out with a quiet and elegant bayside spot.
1 - 16 of 16 |
