The Hamptons - Restaurants - Italian

56 Nugent St., The Hamptons
(631) 377-3611

Tutto Il Giorno Southampton

Everything about the original Tutto Il Giorno in Sag Harbor was tiny except the wait to get in. Its days of being known as "Waverly East" may be over since an ownership change turned it into "Donna... read more

104 North Main St., The Hamptons 11937
631-267-3500

Serafina

Crew from midtown NYC stalwart moves into former Matto space, signature pizzas in hand (more than two dozen of 'em, in fact). Of course, there's also the expected staples -- from Parma to paillard ... read more

2402 Montauk Hwy., The Hamptons 11932
631-537-7999

World Pie

There are few better ways to bend a buck in Bridgehampton than perching at a sidewalk table with a decent bottle of wine and a pie from the wood burning oven while watching the shitshow parade by. ... read more

1524 Northern Blvd., The Hamptons 11030
516-365-6956

Stresa

It might look like the catering hall where your cousin had his wedding, but get past that. Terrific Northern Italian (mainly Tuscan) fare will you help you forget your surroundings, and a well roun... read more

136 North Main St., The Hamptons 11937
631-324-3550

Nick & Toni's

The most sought-after seat in the Hamptons, this East End version of “Spago” attracts celebrities in droves (your basic Jack, Brad, Gwyneth). Central to three Mediterranean-style dining rooms is a ... read more

468 W. Lake Dr., The Hamptons 11954
631-668-9190

Dave's Grill

Seafood so fresh, the trawlers that bring it dot the horizon and come in to dock at next door Montauk Harbor—though the dining room is a bit more refined than that might suggest. Reservation ... read more

30 Main St., The Hamptons 11978
631-283-1233

Sant Ambroeus

Another NYC institution makes its way out East. Elegant bakery-cum-patisserie in front, supper-club-like Northern Italian restaurant hidden in back. Socials and family-types stop in for the tasty s... read more

36 Newtown Ln., The Hamptons 11937
631-324-5900

Sam's Bar and Restaurant

This old school pizza and pasta joint is something of an East Hampton landmark. The orange glow of its neon beckons you to come into the dim bar and no-frills dining room for a stout or glass of wi... read more

29 Newtown Ln., The Hamptons 11937
631-324-6300

CittaNuova

It’d be lost in Manhattan, but the thoroughly modern spin on Northern Italian is welcome on Newton Lane. With garden seating out back and sidewalk seating in front your al fresco dining optio... read more

5 Bay St, The Hamptons 11963
631-725-7009

Tutto Il Giorno

Rustic Italian served in a quaint cottage, complete with warm yellow walls bedecked with paintings of the Italian countryside. Hamptonites, tourists, and celebrities frequent this Maurizio Marfogli... read more

75 Main St., The Hamptons 11968
631-283-7575

75 Main

75 Main was made for a sunny Southampton afternoon. The front windows are open and sidewalk seating is packed with the rich and the beautiful. The glorious sea breeze wafts through the open windows... read more