It was bound to happen. The Dark Knight has garnered its first negative review and it comes from New York Magazine critic David Edelstein. The film was sporting a 100% fresh rating at Rotten Tomatoes until Edelstein came along and spoiled the party. He called Heath Ledger's performance, which has earned unanimous raves, "painful to watch," and wrote that "scarier than what the Joker does to anyone onscreen is what Ledger must have been doing to himself." As for the film's script, it's as if it was written by "Oxford philosophy majors trying to tone up a piece of American pop." And speaking of Oxford philosophy majors, it seems as though one of them eloquently responded to Edelstein's review in the comments section.
Read More »

